top of page

Why Working With the Same Editor Across a Series Helps

Angela Scarborough
Oct 19
3 min read

Quick note before we start: I'm a freelance editor, so I do benefit when an author comes back for the next book. I'll try to be fair about it and include the reasons you might not want to stay with one editor, too.


If you're writing a series, you'll edit more than one book. Plenty of authors end up working with the same editor the whole way through, and there are good reasons for it.


Two tools that make a series easier to edit

A style sheet is a running list of decisions about your book: how you spell made-up names and places, whether you write "okay" or "OK," how you handle numbers, which words you capitalize, and so on. An editor often builds one as they work.


A series bible is the story version of that. It tracks character details like eye color and ages, the timeline, the rules of your world, and who knows what at each point in the story. You can keep one yourself, and it helps no matter who edits you.


Why staying with one editor can help

  • They already know your voice. By book two, an editor knows which quirks are your style and which are mistakes. That means fewer changes you didn't need and more attention on what's actually wrong.

  • Continuity is easier to catch. An editor who read book one remembers that your hero broke his left arm, or that the café burned down. A new editor only has what the following book is about, unless you give them the details.

  • There are fewer questions. With a style sheet already built, the editor doesn't have to stop and ask about every spelling and rule again.

  • You learn across books. When the same editor points out the same habit in book one and book two, it sticks. Authors often find the third manuscript comes back much cleaner than the first.

  • Style remains the same. Different editors have different processes. And often, it shows throughout the editing. If book one has a different editor than the second, they may suggest changes that don't exactly align with book two. Alternatively, if you use the same throughout the series, the story flows seamlessly.

  • Trust builds. Once you know how an editor gives feedback and they know how you take it, the process gets smoother.


When it might not be the right call

  • Fresh eyes have value. Someone who has read every book in the series can get used to your habits. A new editor may spot something the old one stopped seeing.

  • Availability. Your editor may be booked when your next book is ready. Waiting a few weeks may or may not be worth it to you.

  • Fit matters more than loyalty. If the working relationship isn't good, or the editor isn't right for where the series is heading, it's fine to move on.

  • There are no guarantees. Staying with one editor doesn't promise a flawless book. Editors are human, so they can miss a thing or two (take a look at Danielle Steel's many mistakes!) You still need to read your own work carefully. There are also groups on Facebook you can join if something doesn't seem right to you.


If you do switch, you haven't lost everything. Hand the new editor your style sheet and series bible, and they can pick up where the last one left off.


How to get the most out of a long-term editor

  • Send the style sheet and your series notes (if you have one) with every new book.

  • Book your next edit early, even before the draft is finished.

  • Keep a list of feedback that keeps coming up and check your draft against it before you send it.

  • There will be some times where you don't accept an editor's changes. Tell your editor what you disagreed with and why. It helps them understand your choices.


Not sure whether I'm the right editor for your series? I offer a free 1,000-word sample edit so you can see how I work before you commit to anything. You can ask for yours on the Scarborough Editorial website.

Comments


bottom of page