What Happens in a Free Sample Edit (and How to Use One to Choose an Editor)
Hiring an editor means trusting someone with a book you've probably spent months or even years on. A sample edit is the best way to find out whether you're a good fit before you commit. Not every editor offers one. Some may even charge a small fee, but when you're handing over your baby (and your hard-earned money), you deserve to know it's a match. Here's what happens in mine, and how to get the most out of one, whoever you choose.
What happens in my free sample edit
You email me about your manuscript: your name, genre, approximate word count, which service you're interested in, and where the manuscript is in the process.
I reply within 48 hours, usually sooner.
I edit the first 1,000 words of your manuscript for free, no strings attached. I accept Word or Google Docs.
You look at the result and decide whether we're a good fit.
What to send
Send the first 1,000 words of your manuscript, or as close as a natural stopping point allows. Choose a version you're reasonably happy with, not a first rough pass. Editors can tell a lot from clean pages, and you'll get a better idea of what the editing adds.
If you're not sure which service you need, say so in your email. Tell me where the manuscript stands: a first draft, a revised draft, or nearly ready to publish. That helps me point you to the right one. If you want to know what each type of edit does, I explain them in So Many Types of Book Editing! Where to Start?. For rates, see How Much Does a Book Editor Cost?.
How to evaluate a sample edit
Does it still sound like you? A good editor strengthens your voice instead of replacing it.
Do you understand the changes? Comments and explanations should help you learn, not just tell you what to fix.
Is it useful beyond the sample? Look for patterns the editor spots that you can apply to the rest of the book.
How does the feedback read? Honest feedback can still be respectful and encouraging.
Why the first 1,000 words tell you so much
A thousand words is short, but it shows a lot: how you handle openings, your habits with dialogue and description, and whether bigger story questions are already showing up. Even for developmental editing, which looks at a whole book, the opening pages can reveal patterns worth talking about.
I was once told that it's hard to do a developmental edit for the first thousand words. I told them they'd be surprised how much development the first pages need. As writers, we know that the first paragraph is the most important. If it's not gripping, you'll lose the reader. A two-hour movie can get away with thirty minutes of a slow-paced beginning. But an 80,000 word book doesn't have that luxury. Not everyone wants to sit for thirty pages and hope there's a point coming soon.
Questions to ask yourself afterward
Did I learn something I can use right away?
Is this a tone I could work with for an entire book?
Did the editor seem to understand my genre and what I'm trying to do?
Am I more confident about my manuscript, or less?
If you finish a sample excited to start revising, that's a good sign.
If you're comparing editors (which I recommend)
Ask each one for a sample, and send them all the same passage so you can compare apples to apples.
Compare what's included, not just the rate. On an 80,000-word novel, one editor charging $0.03 per word ($2,400) can look cheaper than another charging $0.038 ($3,040). But if the first price covers only developmental editing, and the second covers developmental and line, you'd be paying extra later to get the same result from the first editor. If you need both, the higher price may be the better deal.
Trust your gut. Choose the editor whose feedback makes you excited to open your document and fix things, rather than the one who just gives you the lowest price and does an okay job.
Common mistakes to avoid
Choosing on price alone. The cheapest quote may leave out things you need.
Sending different passages to different editors. You can't compare the results fairly. One section might be in worse shape than the other.
Expecting a sample to fix your book. It's a taste of the process, not a full edit.
Skipping the sample altogether. It's a low-risk way to avoid an expensive mismatch, even if you're charged a small fee.
Frequently asked questions
Is your sample edit really free?
Yes. Mine is free, with no strings attached, and you don't have to hire me afterward.
Can I use my sample for a different type of editing than I plan to buy?
Yes. Tell me which service you're leaning toward, and if you're not sure, I'll help you work out which one fits.
What if I'm not happy with the sample?
That's useful to know, too. A sample is there so you can find out whether we're a good fit, and a "no" simply means you need something a bit different.
If you'd like to try mine, send me your first 1,000 words. You can find the details at scarborougheditorial.com.




Comments