What to Expect After You Hire a Book Editor
Hiring an editor for the first time is easier when you know what the process looks like. Who sends what? When does the money change hands? What happens to your manuscript while you wait?
Every editor works a little differently, so I'll go through the common pattern first and then show how it works with me.
Step 1: You get in touch
Editors usually ask for a few things up front: your genre, your word count, the type of edit you want, and where the manuscript is in the process. Many also ask to see a sample from the book. The word count and the sample are what an editor needs to quote a price, because the cost depends on how long the book is and how much work it needs. If you're not sure which type of edit you need, I explain them in So Many Types of Book Editing! Where to Start?.
Step 2: The sample edit
Many editors offer a sample edit. Ask whether it's free or paid. A sample shows you how the editor works and what their feedback looks like, and it shows them whether your manuscript is a good fit.
Step 3: Agreeing on the details
Before work starts, get the details in writing. It doesn't have to be a formal contract. Editing associations say a written agreement can be as simple as a set of emails. What matters is that it covers:
The service you're buying and what it includes
The word count the price is based on
The price and payment terms
The schedule, including start and delivery dates
What you'll receive and in what format
What happens if either of you needs to cancel or reschedule
Step 4: Deposit and payment
Payment terms vary a lot. Many editors ask for a deposit to hold a spot on their calendar, with the rest paid partway through or at delivery. One editing guide says deposits commonly range from a flat fee of $100 or more up to half of the total, and another puts it at up to 50 percent. Some editors expect the full balance before they send back the edited file, while others invoice when the work is finished. For typical per-word rates, see How Much Does a Book Editor Cost?.
So ask three things. How much is the deposit? When is the rest due? And is the deposit refundable if your schedules change?
If the project changes
Sometimes a manuscript turns out to need more work than the quote assumed. A professional editing association says that if the job becomes more time consuming or complicated than expected, the editor shouldn't charge more than the agreed amount unless you agree to it. The editor may pause until you've settled on a new fee. That's one more reason to have the agreement in writing before you start.
Rates can also go up for some jobs, such as a rush turnaround. If you need your edit faster than usual, ask about it before you book.
Step 5: Waiting your turn
Some editors book weeks or months ahead, so ask for their next open date. Once your manuscript is with the editor, try not to keep revising your own copy. The editor is working on the version you sent, and changes you make on the side won't line up with their edits. If you realize something needs fixing, tell your editor instead of sending a new file without warning.
Big projects can be done in stages
With a large project, some editors will work in stages, like a few chapters at a time. If that's the plan, you and your editor may want to talk after each stage about how it went and what comes next. Editors who work this way often ask for payment as each stage is finished, so check that in the agreement.
Step 6: Delivery
How long editing takes varies, depending on the type of edit, the length of the book, and the editor's schedule. Developmental editing usually takes the longest. When it's done, you'll typically get your edited file back in Word with tracked changes. Some editors also include a style sheet, which is a running list of the spelling, punctuation, and name choices made in your book, and a summary of any larger issues they spotted.
Then it's your turn. Read the feedback once, wait a day or two before reacting, and ask questions if something isn't clear.
Some editors send back two copies of the manuscript: one with track changes and one with the changes already accepted. That’s a nice gesture, but I still recommend going through every change yourself.
Some editors put their comments inline with the tracked changes instead of in the margins. If you accept everything without reading, you can miss those notes and publish with edits you never actually looked at.
Editors also make mistakes. They’re human, too. An editor might make dozens of good changes and still type “graet” instead of “great.”
How it works with me
Here's my process:
Say hello. Email me about your manuscript, and I'll be in touch within 48 hours, usually less.
Free sample. I edit your first 1,000 words for free so you can see how I work before committing.
We agree. If we're a good fit, we confirm the scope, rate, and timeline, so everything is clear upfront.
Delivery. Your edited manuscript comes back within two weeks, with tracked changes and a detailed editorial note if you chose developmental.
Frequently asked questions
Do I really need a contract?
You need a written agreement. A formal contract is one way to do it, but a clear email exchange can work too. Either way, you and your editor should both be able to point to what was agreed.
What do I send to get a quote?
Your word count, your genre, the service you're interested in, and a sample of the manuscript if the editor asks for one. I accept manuscripts in Word or Google Docs.
What should I do while I wait?
Start thinking about your next project, or take a break. If you can, avoid reading the manuscript again until the edit comes back, so you can see the changes with fresh eyes.
If you'd like to see how I work before you commit to anything, I offer a free 1,000-word sample edit with every new inquiry. You can find the details at scarborougheditorial.com.




Comments