top of page

Thriller Manuscript Checklist: 7 Things to Check Before You Hire an Editor

Angela Scarborough
Oct 22
6 min read

Thrillers are one of the genres I know best, and the same problems show up again and again in manuscripts. If you're about to send yours to an editor, or you're still revising, here are seven things to check first.


1. Does the opening hook?

Start where something is already happening or about to go wrong. Backstory and setup can come later, once readers care what happens next.


Quick test: read your first page and ask what question it raises. If you can't name one, readers may not have a reason to keep going.


2. Are the stakes clear and rising?

Readers should know what your protagonist stands to lose, and that cost should grow as the story goes on. If the stakes stay the same, the tension dissipates.


Quick test: write one sentence about what's at risk at the start, the middle, and the end. Each one should be bigger or more personal than the one before.


3. Is there pressure on the clock?

A deadline, a closing window, or a threat that's getting closer keeps scenes moving. Without any pressure, even exciting events can seem optional.


Quick test: pick a scene from the middle of the book and ask what happens if the characters wait a day. If the answer is nothing, the scene needs more urgency.


4. Do your chapter endings make readers turn the page?

Look at how each of your chapters ends. If all of them ends on a cliffhanger, readers start to see it coming. If a chapter just ends with everything seeming to have settled, it gives them a spot to set the book aside and start dinner. Try ending some chapters with a question, some with a surprise, and some with a new piece of information.


Quick test: Here’s a quick way to see all your chapter endings at once. Copy the last sentence of every chapter into one list. Then read it straight through.


Say your list looks like this:

  • Chapter 1: Then the lights went out.

  • Chapter 2: Then the phone rang.

  • Chapter 3: Then she heard footsteps behind her.


Every ending is a cliffhanger, so a reader will start to expect one. Now say it looks like this:

  • Chapter 1: And then the real work would begin. (a promise of what’s coming)

  • Chapter 2: He left the office and headed to the helipad. (a quiet, plain ending)

  • Chapter 3: “Yeah, and why? It’s one of life’s greatest mysteries.” (dialogue that leaves a question hanging)


5. Are your twists fair?

A twist works when the reader looks back and sees the clues were there on a reread. It fails when the answer comes out of nowhere. If the culprit is someone the reader barely met, or a character suddenly knows something the story never showed, readers will call it cheating.


Plant your clues early and hide them in plain sight. Put a clue in a scene that’s about something else, or tuck it between two other details so it doesn’t stand out. Then mention it again later in a different way. One clue is easy to miss. Two or three add up.

Red herrings are false clues that point toward the wrong answer. They should be believable. Give the wrong suspect a real reason to look guilty and make sure that reason has an honest explanation once the truth comes out. A red herring that leads nowhere, or never gets explained, just wastes the reader’s time.


Quick test: go back to the reveal and list every clue that points to it. Write down which chapter each one is in. If you can’t find any in the earlier chapters, the twist will look like a trick. Then do the same with your red herrings. For each one, write down the real explanation. If you don’t have one, that red herring needs work.


One more check: ask someone to read up to the reveal and tell you what they think is going to happen, and why. If they guess it right away, your clues may be too obvious. If they’re completely surprised and can’t see how they’d have known, you may need more. Either answer helps.


6. Does the plot hold up?

Thrillers are full of timelines, alibis, and cause and effect, so plot holes are easy to create. A character ends up in two places at once. Someone knows a secret before anyone told them. A drive takes an hour in chapter 3 and four hours in chapter 20.


Ask whether your characters act in character, or only because the plot needs them to. If you have to stretch to explain why someone makes a choice, readers will notice.


Quick test: build a simple timeline of the story’s events. Put a date and time on every event, and note who is there and who finds out about it afterward. Then go through it one event at a time and ask: could this person really be here, and could they really know this yet? Gaps and contradictions show up fast.


You don’t need software for this. Index cards, a notebook, or a spreadsheet with one row per event all work. If you want a tool, I love Aeon Timeline. You add each event, tag the characters and places in it, and look at the story in different views, including a timeline and a grid of who is in which events. It can also keep your events in the order they happened separately from the order you tell them, which helps if you use flashbacks or jump around in time. It has a free 14-day trial and runs on Mac, Windows, and iOS.


Many writers also use Scrivener. It’s built for writing the manuscript itself. Each chapter or scene is its own section that you can rearrange, with a space for notes and a short summary on each one. I can’t speak to it from experience, but Aeon Timeline can sync with Scrivener so your scene order matches in both. (The sync works on Mac and Windows, not iOS.)


7. Is your protagonist driving the story?

If your hero only reacts, the story can seem like it's happening to them. Look for moments where they make choices that change the direction of the plot. Make sure your antagonist has a believable motive, too.


Quick test: list the major turning points and note who caused each one. If most were caused by someone or something other than your protagonist, give them more control.


How to use this checklist

Read through the seven questions once and be honest about each one. Fix what you know is off. For the ones you can’t tell, ask a friend or an editor to look. It’s hard to see problems in your own book.


Try reading the manuscript in as few sittings as you can. Thrillers are built on momentum, and a dip in tension is easier to spot when you read the story in big chunks instead of one scene at a time. I cover pacing for romance in 5 Common Pacing Problems in Romance Novels (and How to Fix Them).


What to fix yourself, and what to hand to an editor

Some of these are easy to fix on your own: a slow opening, repetitive chapter endings, or a missing deadline. Others are harder to judge on your own, like whether your twist is fair or whether your protagonist is active enough. A fresh reader can see those much more easily than you can.


It's worth fixing the obvious problems first, so your editor's time goes toward the deeper questions instead of things you could have caught yourself.


What a developmental edit looks at in a thriller

A developmental edit looks at plot holes, structure and pacing, character goals and growth, and emotional depth. In a thriller, those map onto the questions in this checklist: are the stakes clear, does the timeline hold up, and is your protagonist making the choices that drive the story. In my developmental edits, you get an editorial letter with the big-picture notes, plus comments in the manuscript. I explain each type of edit in So Many Types of Book Editing! Where to Start?.


If you're not sure whether you need a developmental edit, a beta read is a good way to find out how a reader reacts before you commit to spending more money.


Three habits that help while you revise

  • Keep a one-page list of your scenes, with one line on what changes in each.

  • Keep a running timeline as you go, so you don't have to rebuild it later.

  • Write down what each major character wants in each scene they're in.


When is a thriller ready for an editor?

  • You've finished a complete draft, with a beginning, middle, and end.

  • You've done at least one revision pass on your own.

  • You can describe your story's main conflict and stakes in a sentence or two.

  • You're ready for honest feedback and have time to act on it.


I'd be happy to take a look. I offer a free 1,000-word sample edit for every new inquiry. You can find the details at scarborougheditorial.com.

Comments


bottom of page